Just finished reading Catcher in the Rye.

At least the third time I’ve read it – maybe another in high school? – with a different reaction each time.

The first time, I thought it was the greatest book ever written. Amazing, no phonies. 

The next time, I was relatively goddam unimpressed.

This time, still processing, my reaction somewhere in the middle.

The subject matter: Teenage angst leading to a nervous breakdown, hit differently this time.

Holden ending up in a sanitarium, maybe the early ‘50s data centers – We don’t want them anywhere near here! NIMB! But that might have been where my uncle Billy ended up – he was mustard gassed in WW1.

A large part of the different hit, the death of Holden’s younger brother Allie from leukemia, the catalyst for his emotional issues. Too close to recent family history, keeping me squirming as I read.

The possible lesson, our reaction to books, movies, music – possibly everything – shaped by where we are in our lives.

By our current life circumstance.

Influencing our view of everything; coloring our relationships with family, friends – the world at large. How enthusiastically I wave at my fellow beach walkers, how politely we drive, how we answer our phones.

As My Captor says surveying the neighborhood, “A lot goes on behind those windows.”

Or could it be the Would you go back? question – can anything ever be as good as the first time?

For me, that’s ‘Elsa, the Amorous Lioness’, a song by Shirley Bassey (Shakes fist angrily! at time and memory, because upon googling and Spotifying, I might not recall either her name or the song title – lost like so many other details), a song I heard on WGN radio in Chicago, circa 1977.

At the time, the most amazing piece of music, ever.

I’ve never heard it again.

But what if I had? I’ve looked for it out of one eye in record stores (kids, ask your parents), secretly thrilled at each non-find. I don’t believe it could ever be as good as my first listen.

It could be circumstances. With My Captor – then My Future Captor – in a car on a double date, heading up Lake Shore Drive on a beautiful Chicago night.

But what if I hadn’t? Maybe imagined, added to the list of fictional things I’ve really enjoyed. A future benefit of mild (hopefully) dementia. 

As an aside, I know a lot of you are remembering a favorite restaurant, book or movie better with time, but that doesn’t fit with the theme, so please keep them to yourself.  

Are we victims of expectations? Do we want too much?

Or victims of memory? Do we glamorize past experiences more than they deserve…

Marriages subject to circumstances too. Perfect matches who don’t work out, frequently because of where their lives are. Maybe unfortunate personal habits that later get corrected – too late.  

Applying to relationships as well. I have a mental catalog of ‘people I could have been friends with’; generally short circuited by too little time – or indifference. Forcing me to remember it’s not that hard making that extra effort, ultimately, done in by indifference.

Another mental catalog of friends ‘who I could be a better friend to’. Labeled as When was the last time I talked to …

Phone calls a great New Years Resolution, heh?

Hopefully that description doesn’t apply to those you love.

After all that, still not sure what to make of CITR.

Is it me? Was I still expecting the greatest book ever written?

Or is it Holden? A friend I didn’t have the time or energy for?

ENHANCE YOUR ENJOYMENT OF THIS POST, PAIR WITH THE FOLLOWING ‘AGING HIPSTER MUSIC/READING’:

Technology, am I right? My very old and decrepit computer -we have a lot in common – finally came on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *